Olive Films

[Moe Dickstein]

The Quiet Man is supposed to be pretty bad too.

[captveg]

I thought Body Snatchers and Johnny Guitar had problems? Forgot what, but that's why I held off on them.

Invasion of the Body Snatchers is fine. It's fairly grainy because of its conversion to Superscope 2.00:1, but that's hardly the fault of Olive.

Johnny Guitar is fine aside from the fact that it's open matte 1.37:1 instead of matted 1.66:1. But since it's been seen at 1.37:1 for several generations now some may be willing to give it a pass there.

[chatterjees]

What's wrong with The Quiet Man? :-k

[domino harvey]

XXX @ "Bad"

[Gregory]

The Quiet Man is supposed to be pretty bad too.

What do you mean "supposed to be"? Have you seen it?

[swo17]

Quiet Man and Johnny Guitar, though they could be improved upon, are by far the best home video versions available for these films.

[HJackson]

What's wrong with The Quiet Man? :-k

Very little. But Robert Harris doesn't like it, therefore it's shit.

[Moe Dickstein]

What's wrong with The Quiet Man? :-k

Very little. But Robert Harris doesn't like it, therefore it's shit.

No offense, but I'll take his word over yours on matters of film restoration.

[Lowry_Sam]

I thought Body Snatchers and Johnny Guitar had problems? Forgot what, but that's why I held off on them.

DVD Beaver on Johnny Guitar:

The new Olive Blu-ray is superior to all the SD-DVDs and, remarkably, is the only digital edition in accurate theatrical running time. Colors gain vibrancy, detail and contrast advance and there are far fewer artefacts although there are still some light scratches and speckles on the 1080P source. Certainly this is the edition to own with modest lossless sound (no subtitle options) and a cool 3.5-minute appreciation by Martin Scorsese. This is iconic cinema and we give a full endorsement to the Olive Films Blu-ray package. This is great news!

NOTE: The film was originally composed for 1.66:1 and the Olive Films Blu-ray is, like the DVDs, approximately 1.33:1. (Thanks Bob!)

In the Crawford (w/ Little Rid Riding Hood outfit) grab, the Olive looks overly red in comparison to the Spanish dvd, but I don't know how it's supposed to look. Otherwise, color & detail is better than any other options, though it doesn't even fill 20G of a single-sided disc, which is the biggest problem of most Olive blu-rays (but most titles won't get blu-ray release anywhere else anytime soon).

There is an error (manufacturing?) in at least some copies of Letter From An Unkown Woman, where the image breaks up a couple minutes before the end. I emailed Olive, but never got a response.Really wished Criterion had grabbed this one, Johnny Guitar, & The Pawnbroker, which was supposedly on schedule to be released for over a year now.

Otherwise, my favorites so far are:

Force Of Evil
Body and Soul
Dark City
Appointment With Danger
Despair
Macbeth (if you like theater/Shakespeare)
Betty Boop (if you like vintage cartoons)
The Magic Christian (but I'd only recommend it to people who enjoy off-beat experiments from late 60s & early 70s, think Head meets Medium Cool)

[HJackson]

What's wrong with The Quiet Man? :-k

Very little. But Robert Harris doesn't like it, therefore it's shit.

No offense, but I'll take his word over yours on matters of film restoration.

Thank you for passing on this key piece of information. I'll be sure to file it somewhere safe.

[Askew]

Quiet Man and Johnny Guitar, though they could be improved upon, are by far the best home video versions available for these films.

I'm certainly no expert on the picture quality on these discs, I was only recommending these on the merits of the films themselves, but I can certainly attest to what swo17 says. The Quiet Man, Johnny Guitar and Champion at least are far superior to old DVD editions I owned. I'm still disappointed that Olive has decided that they won't release One of Our Aircraft is Missing since that's another atrocious DVD I was looking forward to replace.

[Drucker]

The Quiet Man does look great, and most of Robert Harris's criticism seems to be that it could have looked better. The technicolor registration isn't nearly perfect (a la Red Shoes) but it is quite good. I will say that Harris mentions something about the image being "brittle" (I think that's the word he uses) and honestly...I kind of see what he's talking about (the image isn't lush), but jeez, if you just want to enjoy the Ford film, the blu ray is lovely (even with possible nit-picking).

Anyway, Champion is a fabulous and great looking film, and Rio Grande also looks great, though I found the film pretty underwhelming.

PS. I thought Nick mentioned somewhere that there is DNR on Johnny Guitar but I can't confirm that.

[EddieLarkin]

The Quiet Man looks fab. If RAH has a problem with it it's because it doesn't look like an original presentation would have. The fine detail, sharpness and natural grain structure are all plain to see. I guess you might have a problem with the colour if you're a 3-strip Technicolor expert. Indeed, even a layman can compare it to something like Meet Me in St Louis or Shane and see that the blacks are horribly milky.

Invasion of the Body Snatchers looks very mediocre though. Cropped from the OAR, transferred from elements 3 or 4 generations from the OCN.

Johnny Guitar looks pretty soft and smudgy, and is open matte.

[doc mccoy]

Thank you for the recommendations

[matrixschmatrix]

Just in terms of quality of the film (my eye's not that great) I'd recommend Rio Grande, The Enforcer, and Secret Beyond the Door, too.

And Force of Evil is amazing, 100% second that rec.

[Gregory]

I find RAH's Few Words About™ The Quiet Man unconvincing because he seems to simply assume that it could have looked close to perfect, and that it does not is all on Olive and their 4k transfer. His comments don't seem to suggest he has any firsthand knowledge of the state of the negative, yet he expects that if Olive knew what they were doing, the Blu-ray should have looked pretty much the film did when it was brand new. He and others on HTF make all kinds of offhand comments about how simple it would have been for Olive to fix the Technicolor registration problems but, unless I'm badly mistaken, it can sometimes be far from an easy problem to fix. Especially if the center of the image is well aligned but areas closer to the edges appear misaligned (as he acknowledges is the case with The Quiet Man), which suggests that it's not a simple kind of alignment problem, and to get it close to perfect would have needed something like Warner's proprietary Ultra-Resolution process, no?
His comments are quite vague about what Olive did wrong, or didn't do, that supposedly caused it to be harsh, "brittle," "gritty," (yet "lacking in texture"? as well as "any real cohesiveness") and "strident-looking" (sounds like we're in the same realm here as indecipherably abstract and poetic wine-writer language).
To me, the Quiet Man disc shows only the expected problems likely inherent in the source elements. RAH seems to argue that all of this could have been solved with more "processing" and "final steps."
Judging from comments in that thread, it seems that some wanted the transfer to be razor-sharp with all alignment problems solved, but not too "hard" or "realistic" looking; sharp and crisp yet at the same time "soft" and "dreamy" [shrug] It must be a drag having such unrealistically high expectations all the time.

[Finch]

I thought The Quiet Man looked fine and after RAH's recommendation of the disastrous Madame de disc, I don't put much store in his opinion.

[chatterjees]

What's wrong with The Quiet Man? :-k

Very little. But Robert Harris doesn't like it, therefore it's shit.

No offense, but I'll take his word over yours on matters of film restoration.

The Quiet Man Blu-Ray (the total package) is so far the best release from Olive! In case of Known films (BDs), you see, I don't read too much before I buy what I wanna buy and watch what I wanna watch! It looked stunning on my 55" LED! The only issue I have with any Olive release is the lack of subs. The Quiet Man BD is not an exception. Other than that, I am really happy with my $14.63 purchase from importcds, and the package also includes a booklet!

So far I own 20 Olive BDs, and The Quiet Man is the best looking one, PQ/SQ wise! That's only my opinion though

[Roger Ryan]

Invasion of the Body Snatchers looks very mediocre though. Cropped from the OAR, transferred from elements 3 or 4 generations from the OCN.

There are some DNR issues as well with INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS that does some weird things to faces on occasion (McCarthy's jaw sort of blends into his neck and almost leaves his face at one point), but this is sporadic and seems to not be a problem during the lengthy night sequences.

[Drucker]

I thought The Quiet Man looked fine and after RAH's recommendation of the disastrous Madame de disc, I don't put much store in his opinion.

It seems like you can depend on him panning an Olive release as not good enough and praising a Twilight Time as the best is possible frequently. And if you go back far enough he praises things like The Searchers which is still a very "open for debate" transfer (color-timing wise).

I trust the good folks here more than anyone else on the internet.

[captveg]

Invasion of the Body Snatchers looks very mediocre though. Cropped from the OAR, transferred from elements 3 or 4 generations from the OCN.

There are some DNR issues as well with INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS that does some weird things to faces on occasion (McCarthy's jaw sort of blends into his neck and almost leaves his face at one point), but this is sporadic and seems to not be a problem during the lengthy night sequences.

And its not like the aspect ratio and later generation issues are avoidable. The film was cropped to 2.00:1 and distributed in Superscope in the 50s, causing these issues immediately. As far as I know the earlier elements are not known to currently exist.

[kingofthejungle]

I'll second almost all of the Olive titles that have been recommended so far (the one exception being Champion, which I thought was a pretty lackluster film). I especially want to join in the praise for all of the John Ford films they've released so far. I want to add a few of my own favorite Olive titles to the list as well.

Crashout - This is a superb little noir starring Arthur Kennedy and William Bendix, directed by Lewis R. Foster and lenses by Russell Metty. I consider it one of Olive's great discoveries.

Samuel Fuller's China Gate
Raoul Walsh's Dark Command
Leo McCarey's My Son John - This is a controversial one, to be sure. It's got some histrionic right-wing politics being voiced, but it's far more nuanced and complex than it's detractors seem to believe. The image is a little soft, but I consider this film an essential McCarey masterpiece, and it's been previously unavailable.
Andre de Toth's Ramrod - a very good noir/western starring Joel McCrea and the beautiful Veronica Lake.
Robert Aldrich's Twilight's Last Gleaming

Also, an honorable mention to the later Cary Grant films (The Grass Is Greener, Father Goose, etc), the films of poverty row's answer to Orson Welles - John Auer (Hell's Half Acre, A Man Betrayed), Panama and Frank's The Trap, and Lewis Allen's Appointment With Danger.

[domino harvey]

Of the less visible titles, my favorite is certainly the Devil and Miss Jones, which repairs Jean Arthur and Charles Coburn and is arguably the best film of both. A hilarious socially-conscious comedy about a department store boss who masquerades as an employee at his own store to spy on the union and ends up falling for the lower class. It was my spotlight title in the 40s List, but since at the time there was no home video release, I don't think very many people saw it. It also has my fav opening credits ever:

[AfterTheRain]

I'll put in my input on some of Olive's releases that I would recommend:

William Castle's Project X
Hit!
Escape From Zahrain
Rope of Sand
Union Station
Crack in the World
Joseph Losey's The Lawless

[Grisbi]

I've blind bought a good handful of Olive titles, and while I've yet to be flat out disappointed by any of them yet, my favorite discoveries that I would recommend with no reservations are BLOWING WILD (Fregonese) and RUTHLESS (Ulmer).

TWILIGHT'S LAST GLEAMING is probably my favorite overall release of the ones I own - essential film from an essential director, great looking transfer and an excellent, substantial documentary as an extra.