solent wrote:
in terms of collecting I would stop at the BBC versions.
The quality of the BBC cycle varies enormously, and some of the most famous plays got the dullest adaptations (
As You Like It, Romeo and Juliet, The Tempest) - so I really wouldn't recommend stopping there!
Antony and Cleopatra and
Macbeth were better, but both were massively overshadowed by Trevor Nunn's RSC productions, which were adapted for television in the 1970s (the Nunn
Macbeth, with Ian McKellen and Judi Dench, is available on DVD, and for my money is the best television adaptation of any Shakespeare play).
The year of production often makes a difference - the first two BBC seasons (1978-80) were produced by Cedric Messina, who firmly believed in a conservative "bring the Bard to the masses" approach, with texts generally cut to about two hours and resoundingly conventional staging. By general consent the worst productions date from that era, though there are a few gems -
Measure for Measure was terrific, as was the rarely-staged
Henry VIII, while the
Richard II/Henry IV/Henry V cycle was very watchable.
Things improved significantly from the third season onwards when Jonathan Miller took over, and completely reversed Messina's policy by openly encouraging his directors to be adventurous (albeit within some fairly strict bounds dictated by the co-production agreement with Time-Life Television). His regime was also marked by unconventional casting - John Cleese as Petruchio, Bob Hoskins as Iago.
The three primary directors of the Miller era were Miller himself, Elijah Moshinsky and Jane Howell, who collectively made some of the cycle's strongest adaptations - Miller did
The Taming of the Shrew, Troilus and Cressida (a personal favourite of his),
Timon of Athens, a contentious
Othello (though Anthony Hopkins was a last-minute substitute for James Earl Jones, banned from appearing by Equity) and a
King Lear that was essentially an extended version of his 1975 BBC production with many of the same actors, as he didn't believe he'd changed his view of the play.
Moshinsky often made significant changes to the text (heavy cuts, reshuffled scenes), and sometimes his extraordinarily lush visuals worked against the original (
A Midsummer Night's Dream), but his most successful productions (
All's Well That Ends Well, Cymbeline, Coriolanus) were sometimes thrillingly ambitious. Howell arguably went even further, with her ultra-stylised
Winter's Tale, children's adventure playground restaging of the
Henry VI/Richard III cycle and an admirably restrained and sober
Titus Andronicus.
I covered the cycle for BFI Screenonline a couple of years ago - more details
here