Re: The 1940s List: Discussion and Suggestions (Decade Project Vol. 4)
Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2026 6:05 pm
The Cross of Lorraine is a mixed bag. The momentum gains and loses energy in strange intervals - it has an episodic nature that's not supported by the overall narrative structure, and the acting isn't great. But there are enough surprising and exciting inclusions to warrant a soft recommendation. Firstly, there are some creative devices utilized by the POWs to gain small wins over the Nazis, particularly in a scene where Cronyn gets his comeuppance. And the violence is extraordinary, going above and beyond what I expected was even allowed at this time. The very ending is a showstopper, but the way Lorre gets taken out is gruesome, and there are a handful of scenes that startle with brief pockets of suspense. Unfortunately the rest of the picture just doesn't measure up - these strange pieces don't have cohesion, so the whole thing kind of exists as a patched-together curio