criterionforum.org

I'm surprised they're listing the Lumière set as DVD, because a BD release exists.
If anybody can tell them so it could be corrected, I havent found how to contact them myself.

2016 Winners.

Dvd Awards 2017 Finalists:

DEKALOG
(Poland, 1985) by Krzysztof Kieślowski
Arrow Films (blu-ray + dvd)

BRING ME THE HEAD OF ALFREDO GARCIA
(USA, 1974) by Sam Peckinpah
Arrow Films (blu-ray)

NAPOLEON
(France, 1927) by Abel Gance
BFI (blu-ray)

DISSENT & DISRUPTION. ALAN CLARKE AT THE BBC
(UK, 1969-1989)
BFI (blu-ray + dvd)

COFFRET L’ÂGE D’OR DU CINÉMA JAPONAIS
(France-Japan, 1939-1964)
Carlotta Films (dvd)

AMARCORD
(Italy, 1973) by Federico Fellini
CG Entertainment (blu-ray + dvd)

LA VIE EST À NOUS, LE TEMPS DES CERISES ET AUTRES FILMS DU FRONT POPULAIRE
(France, 1936-1937) by Jean Renoir, Jean-Paul Le Chanois
Ciné-Archives (dvd)

PRIVATE PROPERTY
(USA, 1960) by Leslie Stevens
Cinelicious Pics (blu-ray)

MARGOT DIAS: FILMES ETNOGRÁFICOS (1958-1961)
(Portugal, 1958-1961)
Cinemateca Portuguesa – Museu do Cinema / Direção-Geral do Património Cultural, Museu Nacional de Etnologia (dvd)

DÉJÀ S’ENVOLE LA FLEUR MAIGRE
(Belgium, 1960) by Paul Meyer
CINEMATEK (dvd)

JACQUELINE VEUVE – RÉTROSPECTIVE
(Swiss, 1966-2010)
Cinémathèque suisse/Cin&Lettres/Radio Télévision Suisse (dvd)

CHIMES AT MIDNIGHT
(Spain, 1966) by Orson Welles
Criterion (blu-ray)

THE KENNEDY FILMS OF ROBERT DREW & ASSOCIATES
(USA, 1960-1964) by Robert Drew
Criterion (blu-ray)

WAJDA
(Poland, 1954-2013)
Cyfrowe Repozytorium Filmowe (Digital Film Repository) (dvd)

MARTIN SCORSESE PRESENTS: MASTERPIECES OF POLISH CINEMA
(Poland, 1958-1988)
di Factory (blu-ray)

RUSHES DE BRUNO MUEL/AVEC LE SANG DES AUTRES
(France, 1974) by Bruno Muel
Editions Commune (dvd)

THE SALVATION HUNTERS
(USA, 1925) by Josef von Sternberg
Edition Filmmuseum (dvd)

K.u.K. KINOBOX. DIE DONAUMONARCHIE IN ORIGINALEN FILMDOKUMENTEN
(varie, 1896-1918)
Filmarchiv Austria/Ernst Kieninger,Nikolaus Wostry (dvd)

WOMAN ON THE RUN
(USA, 1950) by Norman Foster
Flicker Alley, LLC./The Film Noir Foundation (blu-ray + dvd)

OPFERGANG
(Germany, 1944) by Veit Harlan
Friedrich-Wilhelm-Murnau-Stiftung/Concorde Home Entertainment (blu-ray)

IMMENSEE
(Germany, 1943) by Veit Harlan
Friedrich-Wilhelm-Murnau-Stiftung/Concorde Home Entertainment (blu-ray)ì

UN CARNET DE BAL
(France, 1937) by Julien Duvivier
Gaumont Vidéo (dvd/blu-ray)

RENDEZ-VOUS DE JUILLET
(France, 1949) by Jaques Becker
Gaumont Vidéo (dvd/blu-ray)

VINICIUS DE MORAES, UM RAPAZ DE FAMÍLIA
(Brazil, 1983) by Susana Moraes
Instituto Moreira Salles (dvd)

PIONEERS OF AFRICAN-AMERICAN CINEMA
(USA, 1915-1944)
Kino Lorber (blu-ray)

COLOUR BOX: 19 FILMS BY LEN LYE
(USA-New Zeland, 1929-1980)
Len Lye Foundation/Govett-Brewster Art Gallery/Ngā Taonga Sound and Vision (dvd)

TRESORS DU CINEMA YIDDISH
(Poland-USA-Germany, 1936-1949)
Lobster Films (dvd)

THE MAGIC BOX: PROJECT SHIRLEY VOLUME 4: THE FILMS OF SHIRLEY CLARKE
(USA, 1929-1987)
Milestone Film & Video (blu-ray + dvd)

TONKA ŠIBENICE
(Czech, 1930) by Karel Anton
Národní filmový archiv/Filmexport Home Video (dvd)

GOOD AFTERNOON
(Australia, 1971) by Phil Noyce
National Film and Sound Archive of Australia (dvd)

LE CARROSSE D’OR
(Italy, 1952) by Jean Renoir
Raro Video (dvd)

LES SAISONS – UNE TÉTRALOGIE DE MARCEL HANOUN
(France, 1968-1972)
Re:Voir Video (dvd)

PEOPLE OF THE MOUNTAINS
(Hungary, 1942) by István Szőts
Second Run (dvd)

ROBERT FRANK: FILM WORKS
(USA, 1959-1975)
Steidl (dvd)

THE MAN WHO FELL TO EARTH
(England, 1976) by Nicolas Roeg
Studiocanal (blu-ray + dvd)

Does Trésors du cinéma Yiddish have English subs?

The Lobster website specifies both French and English "versions," which I can only assume means subtitles. And this article states in the opening paragraph that all the films have subtitles in both languages.

No A Brighter Summer Day? and StudioCanal's awful The Man Who Fell to Earth?

Yeah, there are some weird stuff there.
Why the Raro DVD of Le carosse d'or while the movie has been released on BD in France (I guess the DVD has English subs, the French BD doesn't) ? Why the random Becker movie from Gaumont ? No Pathé restoration, especially none of their Duvivier ? And what is special about this Amarcord release than the Criterion doesn't have ?
But hey, let's drop a non-optimum 4K resto from Studio Canal !

Amarcord is from a brand-new 4K restoration which easily beats Criterion's old master, though I agree it is unworthy given the absence of any extras and an English subtitle.

I assume Arrow's Dekalog was favoured over Criterion's because of the five rare TV movies that mostly aren't available anywhere else.

andyli wrote:Amarcord is from a brand-new 4K restoration which easily beats Criterion's old master, though I agree it is unworthy given the absence of any extras and an English subtitle.

Why exactly would the absence of English subtitles make this release unworthy of nomination for an award at an Italian film festival?

Maybe... the missed chance to attract a wider audience? Again this is just my opinion and does not necessarily conform to Ritrovato's standard. (After all, they did nominate it.)

I have never regarded this award as a Italian or domestic award. It is rather a global survey of worthy releases and is selected by a group of international experts like Jonathan Rosenbaum who consider titles published from all over the world. From past experience, the inclusion of English subtitles has been mentioned from time to time as the (added) value of a winner, such as the Portabella set, Epstein set, and Arté's Out 1 set.

Back to Amarcord, if a label, say Arrow Academy, had put out the 4K master with supplements and English subtitles, I don't see how the Italian release could have competed even though it is the 'native' release.

andyli wrote:I have never regarded this award as a Italian or domestic award. It is rather a global survey of worthy releases and is selected by a group of international experts like Jonathan Rosenbaum who consider titles published from all over the world.

Fair enough, but if the aim is to attract a global audience, why not Mandarin or Spanish subtitles? Not that I'm against English subtitles, but the suggestion that a foreign release is unworthy of international attention without them seems a bit extreme. (And I'm pretty sure that most of the British and American titles nominated don't include subtitles that would make them accessible to the many people in the world who don't understand English.)

tenia wrote: And what is special about this Amarcord release than the Criterion doesn't have ?

It has the special "Ritrovata color"!
http://caps-a-holic.com/c.php?go=1&a=0& ... 61&i=0&l=0" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
http://caps-a-holic.com/c.php?go=1&a=0& ... 63&i=2&l=0" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
http://caps-a-holic.com/c.php?go=1&a=0& ... 68&i=7&l=0" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

L.A. wrote:Does Trésors du cinéma Yiddish have English subs?

Each disc opens with a menu asking the viewer to select FRENCH or ENGLISH. Choose the second and you get English menus and English subs on all bonuses as well as the main features. The accompanying booklet (32 pages) is only in French.

Winners:

Best Rediscovery

DISSENT & DISRUPTION. ALAN CLARKE AT THE BBC
(UK, 1969-1989)
BFI (blu-ray + dvd)

LES SAISONS – UNE TÉTRALOGIE DE MARCEL HANOUN
(France, 1968-1972)
Re:Voir Video (dvd)

Best Special Features

BRING ME THE HEAD OF ALFREDO GARCIA
(USA, 1974) by Sam Peckinpah
Arrow Films (blu-ray)

Best Box Set

DEKALOG
(Poland, 1985) by Krzysztof Kieślowski
Arrow Films (blu-ray + dvd)

PIONEERS OF AFRICAN-AMERICAN CINEMA
(USA, 1915-1944)
Kino Lorber (blu-ray)

Best Single Release

COLOUR BOX: 19 FILMS BY LEN LYE
(USA-New Zeland, 1929-1980)
Len Lye Foundation/Govett-Brewster Art Gallery/Ngā Taonga Sound and Vision (dvd)

Peter von Bagh Award

THE SALVATION HUNTERS
(USA, 1925) by Josef von Sternberg
Edition Filmmuseum (dvd)

Dave Kehr (in addition to Rosenbaum) -- but he is less visible (audible) now that he is engaged in programming...

RINO LUPO: MULHERES DA BEIRA / OS LOBOS (Portugal, 1922-1923) by Rino Lupo – Cinemateca Portuguesa – Museu do Cinema

This one interests me and at least the Portuguese Fnac offer it. I’m going to do a little more research and find out whether it has English subs and if there are other alternatives where to order the DVD.

It's a Fnac exclusive. I can check the back cover in store during the week to verify the actual subs.

Enviado do meu SM-A510F através do Tapatalk

anyone know if that Sucksdorff set has English subs? or all of his short films?

JAP wrote:2018 DVD Awards finalists

Some choices are a bit surprising. For instance, why select Potemkine's Eraserhead which is a lighter version of the Criterion release with no specific editorial input ? Why selecting Second Sight's Color of Pomegranates on DVD and not BD ? Studio Canal picks are also all DVD-only, while BD equivalents exists (and, in the case of The Graduate, would be the logical choice).

In any case though, that's a LOT of finalists, which I guess showcase how many tremendous releases are happening currently.

I don't own the Sucksdorff box. But Studio S say nothing about any subtitles on the website, and nothing on the front or back of the box indicates that it has any subtitles. 4 feature films, 16 shorts + a 4*30 minutes TV-series.

BRANKO GAPO BOX SET (Republic of Macedonia, 1965-1992) – Kinoteka na Makedonija (Dvd)

I think I’m going to bother Kinoteka na Makedonija about this.

L.A. wrote:

BRANKO GAPO BOX SET (Republic of Macedonia, 1965-1992) – Kinoteka na Makedonija (Dvd)

I think I’m going to bother Kinoteka na Makedonija about this.

The boxset contais 6 discs, they have English subtitles, the price is 25 EUR + delivery, can be ordered directly from them and paid by bank transfer only.

djvaso wrote:

L.A. wrote:

BRANKO GAPO BOX SET (Republic of Macedonia, 1965-1992) – Kinoteka na Makedonija (Dvd)

I think I’m going to bother Kinoteka na Makedonija about this.

The boxset contais 6 discs, they have English subtitles, the price is 25 EUR + delivery, can be ordered directly from them and paid by bank transfer only.

Yes, they replied back and the films, the extras and the booklet are English-friendly. 25,00€ for the set and 10,00€ shipping costs to Finland. Doing a bank transfer to Macedonia is difficult. But won’t be giving up.