My chronological progress through the 1950s is slower than Scharphedin2, but I've at least done a preliminary ranking of films from 1950. Most of the films I saw came from Jonathan Rosenbaum's Essential Cinema. In all, I saw all 14 films Rosenbaum had listed for 1950, plus 2 films that Rosenbaum dates as 1949 (Rossellini's Stromboli & Joseph Lewis's Gun Crazy) but that IMDB classifies as 1950. I also Jean-Isidore Isou's Venom and Eternity, which Rosenbaum lists as 1952, but is listed in IMDB as 1950.
So far, here is my ranking for 1950
1. Los Olvidados (Luis Bunuel)
2. Orphee (Jean Cocteau)
3. Aventurera (Alberto Gout)
4. The Flowers of St. Francis (Roberto Rossellini)
5. Un Chant d'Amour (Jean Genet)
Alternates: Story of a Love Affair (Michelangelo Antonioni), Try and Get Me (Cyril Endfield), Gun Crazy (Joseph Lewis), In a Lonely Place (Nicholas Ray)
Contenders I Haven't Seen Yet: La Ronde (Max Ophuls), Caged (John Cromwell), The Furies (Anthony Mann)
Here's Rosenbaum's list from 1950:
All About Eve (Joseph L. Mankiewicz)
Annie Get Your Gun (George Sidney)
Cinderella (Wilfred Jackson / Luske / Clyde Geronimi)
Father of the Bride (Minnelli)
The Flame and the Arrow (Jacques Tourneur)
The Gunfighter (Henry King)
In a Lonely Place (Nicholas Ray)
Los Olvidados (Bunuel)
Orpheus (Cocteau)
Panic in the Streets (Elia Kazan)
Stars in My Crown (Jacques Tourneur)
Sunset Boulevard (Wilder)
Try and Get Me (Endfield)
Wagon Master (Ford)
And here's my recap:
I've seen All About Eve before, but I felt it was overrated. Some of the lines are justifiable classics ("Fasten your seat belts..."), but I felt the film was a little talky. In addition, I kept wishing that Eve was played by Marilyn Monroe (who had a minor role in the film) instead of Anne Baxter. Annie Get Your Gun was an interesting musical with a spirited performance from Betty Hutton, but my favorite musical of 1950 (in addition to being my favorite noir and favorite melodrama) was Aventurera. I saw Cinderella as a kid, but if I vote for a Disney production, I think I might save that vote for the more surrealistic Alice in Wonderland. Vincente Minnelli's Father of the Bride was a pleasant surprise. It was not only leaps and bounds better than Steve Martin remake that I was familiar with, but it has some moments of real poignancy about how an upper middle class father slowly comes to realize that his relationship with his daughter has irrevocably changed. There's even an expressionist dream sequence that takes place the night before his daughter's wedding. Of the two Jacques Tourneur films I saw, The Flame and the Arrow (from my VHS collection) and Stars in My Crown (from an unofficial DVD-R), I preferred The Flame and the Arrow more. It is a rousing swashbuckler that features some fine acrobatics from Burt Lancaster (from Lancaster's pre-Hollywood days as a circus perfomer) in addition to some of Tourneur's unique stylistic touches (atmospheric use of sound, creating suspense in claustrophobic spaces). Stars in My Crown is an unconventional western featuring a Bible-toting sheriff played by Joel McCrea. In fact, the only shots fired in the film are warning shots; the film does not contain a single gunfight. Topics covered in the plot range from a typhoid epidemic to the harassment of property-owning blacks in the Reconstruction-era South, but I still found it a little mild for my tastes.
My favorite three westerns of 1950 were Winchester '73, The Gunfighter, and Wagon Master, but none of the three stuck out as better than the others. The Anthony Mann enthusiasts on this forum have already spoken of Winchester 73's many virtues. Personally, I think it might be interesting to view it as a male version of The Earring of Madame De..., in that both films use totemic objects to illustrate a web of interconnected relationships. Henry King's The Gunfighter is about a gunslinger with a violent reputation, played by Gregory Peck, who can never find any peace, because other gunslingers are always to make themselves famous by gunning him down. Its mournful tone and its acceptance of the unsustainability of the Wild West as a way of life (symbolized by schools and churches as civilizing institutions) make it extremely similar to The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance and some of the revisionist westerns of the 70s. (I saw the Gunfight on a VHS tape that I purchased from a video store liquidating its VHS rentals, but I think a UK release exists.) Finally, Wagon Master shows how masterful John Ford can be in making a "classical" western, even when using the unlikely subject matter of the Mormon migration to Utah. (For example, the Cleggs in Wagon Master are almost as interesting as the Clantons in My Darling Clementine in depicting how an all-male "family" of villains can get warped when kept apart from feminine "civilizing" influences.)
In a Lonely Place made my list of alternates, because I think the film does a better job of depicting the self-destructive relationships between minor celebrities and their fans than any other film that came before. If you want to understand the psychological dynamics between abusive male has-beens (O.J. Simpson, Phil Spector, Robert Blake) and the women who gravitate to them, In a Lonely Place is a good place to start. I liked Panic in the Streets for its noirish atmosphere, its semi-documentary realism, and the basic idea behind a plot that merged chasing a criminal with chasing a deadly disease, but I still can't help that I like Richard Widmark better as an antihero (Pickup on South Street!!) than as a uniformed member of the Establishment. Sunset Boulevard was and is a sentimental favorite of mine, but upon rewatching it, I ranked it lower, because I found the romantic subplot with Nancy Olson as Betty Schaefer to be a weak point of the film. The film gets a good atmosphere going by mixing romantic melodrama with some of the trappings of the "old dark house" genre of Gothic horror, but after seeing it again, I also noticed how Franz Waxman's score was used semi-manipulatively to accomplish the films shifts of tone from cynicism to romanticism to horror and back again.
Jean-Isidore Isou's Venom and Eternity is an experimental film associated with the French avant-garde Lettrist movement that sought to create a "discrepant" cinema that liberated sound from the "tyranny" of the image. (You can view the film online
here.) The images are prosaic depictions, such as of a man walking down the street, almost defiantly prosaic. But the soundtrack is filled with "sound poetry" created by tape manipulation and layering of isolated nonsense syllables, followed by what sounds like a ranting manifesto delivered at a 1950s-era French cine-club. It transfixed me more than some experimental films only 1/10 of its length, but some of it was also maddening, perhaps as its makers intended. I've only seen the film online, but perhaps I can revisit it after re:voir comes out with its promised DVD of the film. Until then, I'll take a page from Andrew Sarris and label it as a "subject for further research."