criterionforum.org

One of the film's best moments hinges entirely upon her subtle expression of genuine disappointment in her father, unfolding in real-time during a karaoke performance. Kudos also has to be given to Wells' exceptional instinct in knowing when to cut from Corio to the words she's reciting off-key and, finally, to Mescal's face, which contains a confluence of disappointment, resentment, and self-loathing. Even more than the much-lauded other musical scene in the film, I'd argue the Losing My Religion sequence provides a supreme example of how minimalist precision can cut right to the heart just as effectively in a nominally mainstream film as much as any intricately edited set piece. The brunt of that scene's emotional impact still rests almost entirely on Corio's young shoulders, and she possesses an emotional maturity and assured sensitivity well beyond her years.

There was one moment in this movie that I thought was interesting which I haven't seen many people comment on. I was wondering if anyone else interpreted it the same way that I did. It's the scene where Sophie is angry that her father didn't join her onstage for karaoke, and she ends up making a cutting comment about how he should stop offering to pay for things when she knows he doesn't have the money. We can see earlier in the movie that she's aware of his financial troubles and is sensitive to them (apologizing for dropping the diving mask that she knew was expensive, etc.), but in the scene I'm talking about she's upset with him, and so she uses that insecurity that she knows he has to hurt him. And you can really see how that comment hurt him, even though he tries to suppress his pain.

Another thing to note is that Welles is very careful to delineate moments that are actual memories from moments that adult Sophie is imagining. Any time Sophie doesn't see something happen it seems like we're supposed to understand that the moment being depicted is imagined. Notably, it seems like Sophie isn't party to most of the moments where her father is most clearly suffering (Calum spitting into the mirror, Calum walking into the ocean, Calum crying on the bed, etc.) so it's almost like those scenes reflect the fact that adult Sophie is trying to imagine the side of him that she never saw.

Anyway, having said all that, I was struck by the staging of this shot: https://imgur.com/a/NvIn1a3

After Sophie says that line to her father, she faces forward and he continues to look at her. In other words, the audience sees Calum's reaction to her comment, but young Sophie doesn't. This implies that adult Sophie is imagining what his reaction to her comment might have been, and how the comment must have hurt him. Adult Sophie then imagines that the comment sent her father into a depressive spiral which culminated in him walking into the ocean, which is how she imagines he might have ended up naked in bed. Again, none of that necessarily happened, but the point is that Sophie made a passive aggressive comment that she thought nothing of at the time, and given the fact that her father committed suicide shortly afterwards, that comment still haunts her decades later. She imagines how that comment might have added to his pain, and feels guilt about it.

I really like this shot because it shows how much thought went into every little detail of this movie. Even the smallest, most seemingly insignificant detail (ie the decision to position the actors so that the audience sees Calum's reaction but Sophie doesn't) conveys so much about adult Sophie's character. It's also impressive how much the movie is able to develop adult Sophie's character despite the fact that she's barely onscreen. In fact, it seems to me like she's the main character; the audience is in her perspective the entire movie. We are seeing moments as she remembers them or imagines them and not as they actually happened, which means that every decision about how to depict a moment reflects something about her character and how she relates to that moment. Aftersun has a very unique way of conveying information which adds to its power; it's the epitome of showing and not telling. The movie doesn't tell us that adult Sophie feels guilt about that comment through ie dialogue, it shows us by showing us the reaction she imagines her father had to what she said.

Did anyone interpret the scene similarly or am I stretching?