The Wolf of Snow Hollow (Jim Cummings)
Have scanned some randos whose dislike for this film seems deeply personal, reaching surprising levels of ferocity considering it’s not a work set on confrontation. Could be borne of frustration; movie’s launched as a werewolf flick, like some of those it hunches like a whodunnit, ain’t much of either. Could be offense taken at its convincing mix of sympathy and disdain for the police –
its imdb “goofs” page is a list of irrelevant occupational inaccuracies. Or resentment of time spent with a central character who’s deeply unpleasant company.
But misdirected seething is thematically appropriate! I suspect the love-its and hate-its are closer at heart than all those whose opinion falls in the meh.
This is Jim Cummings’ second feature as writer-director-star. He specializes in men whose lives are falling apart, enlists every hardship cliché to demonstrate it’s no fault but their own. In
Thunder Road, he plays a police officer named Jim in a small Texas town raising a daughter from a failed marriage while dealing with the death of his mother, a spectrum of anger issues that reaches on beyond infrared, and a cosmetic attempt to quit smoking. In
Wolf, he plays a police officer named John in a small Utah ski resort town raising a daughter from a failed marriage while dealing with the ailing health of his father, a spectrum of anger issues that reaches on beyond infrared, and a history of alcoholism. In the last movie, he had a moustache. In this one, he’s got Robert Forster.
(He’s not a cop in
his new movie, still looks to add to his stable of men who think everything bad is happening to them when a lot of bad is happening because of them.)
But while
Thunder Road could feel like a shapeless indie character study –it wasn’t shapeless, it was bracketed by maternal deaths, built around three desperate long-take monologues (one of them an improvement on
his cringe-comedy short), and piked on a well-executed shock edit reveal, but the ramshackle way it went from A to B to C made it feel shapeless –
Wolf not only has a standard-issue narrative on which to lean, but the added aggravation of that. The only important thing about these werewolf killings or serial murders or whatever the hell they are is that they’re one more thing with which this police officer has to deal, and he’s well past full-up.
Chief among Cummings’ strengths as a writer is that he crafts speeches that fit his mouth. He’s innocuously handsome in an affable way that makes you swear you’ve seen him pass through something, maybe a guest spot on a sitcom, a boyfriend on
New Girl or somesuch; but he does double takes where his smile will drop and eyes shine with contempt, then turns and tears up and bawls open wound wail. His characters are, unfortunately, in roles of authority (father, cop) and are commanding; but they’re not confident, not organized, and they’re aware that, while they’re not incapable idiots, they’re not as smart and capable as they think they should be. So when he gives himself monologues, they play like banter, choppily vacillating between congenial aw-shucks come-on-guys favor-currying, interjected distractions, accusatory outbursts, and apologetically mumbled self-recriminations. When he films himself in long takes, it feels less like performer’s vanity than both a way to frame the character’s selfishness and an unforgiving opportunity to watch him squirm like a bug under glass.
Cummings has great comic timing, can be better at rhythm than content(*), and he uses the tempo in
Wolf to mash everything together. A brisk pace helps forgive rough edges, but staging multiple murders and an investigation and something of a small-town portrait in service of an 85-minute character piece allows him to squeeze that character. It’s not efficiency, it’s technique: There’s a constant clash of tones and concerns, business and personal, and the movie jumps from emotional high note to high note the same way Cummings’ officer swings moods. He exacerbates by cross-cutting events from different time periods – not often flashbacks, mostly new information for the viewer – unified by intensity of emotion. One murder is intercut with a hostile breakfast meeting with his ex-wife; one crime is cut in and out of a confrontational autopsy and the victim’s funeral.
The landing place for all this intensity, the scene that made me finally fall for this film, is a rock-bottom caretaking confrontation between Cummings’ officer and his daughter Jenna. The performances may not be very good, but they’re pretty great, as sloppy as the emotions in play. Jenna’s not on screen in
Wolf a whole lot, but she’s the central concern. Cummings shoehorns her name into his character’s mouth throughout the film at key moments of stress; at first it seems another blurted tangent, but it happens enough it becomes a call to focus. The only insult that lands in the movie – there are several time-stopping duds – comes after the officer slap-fights a coroner and excuses himself with, “I’m a father.” “No, you’re not,” he hears back.
It’s after the killer mentions John’s daughter that the officer keeps from drinking the spiked coffee he accepted. And that she is the real concern of the film helps soften the old trope of the killer threatening the hero’s family; double-helps that it comes about after she’s disrespected the curfew (John’s orders), and triple-helps that she’s pure win in the scene right after the attack.
I found something very real and recognizable in that one father-daughter scene, the one drenched in screams and scared sobs. Obliquely it reminded me of the underlying dynamic in
Stuart Saves His Family, reckoning with all that inherited and casually learned trauma. Cummings watching his father failing, failing his father, failing his daughter, watching his daughter (with her own nascent issues) as she watches her father failing. Remembering the last time he saw his dad, the last time he lied to him. “My father’s face,” he blubbers, pawing at his own. This desperate naked angry weakness, people terrified of themselves and each other. Maybe if you treasure
Stuart Saves His Family (not really a comedy), you’ll also treasure
The Wolf of Snow Hollow (not really a werewolf/serial killer murder mystery).
And it was nice to see the Orion logo again.
(*) Don’t want to eat up even more space, but there are certainly annoyances and legitimate practical concerns that hurt the cause. Like: What’s this department’s 911 response time? Did 90% of the shots have to be a slow push in? (One longer shot actually starts as a slow pull out, then pushes back in.) And
are we ever really supposed to think the lead character is the killer, because despite pronounced canines and an on-the-nose line about “the monsters inside” during an AA meeting, that never, ever registers; in general, the movie takes its red herrings more seriously than I think any viewer ever might.