Maybe. But it seems The Guardian ratings system is a bit different -- "five stars" are possible there, but a maximum of four for the grid. So maybe that accounts for the discrepancy.
If we care about his opinion -- and I don't think I particularly do, though the summaries of his other opinions on the grid are not often especially problematic for me -- here is some of it:
Headline: Hopkins and Hathaway can’t save this stagy tale of a quasi-Trump
First paragraph: This slightly laborious and self-consciously acted family coming-of-age drama features some perfunctory plot resolutions, and dinner-theatre performances from its all-star cast, including Anthony Hopkins, Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway.