From DVD Savant:


Shouldn't Four Devils have (fragments) next to it???

Either way - WONDERFUL NEWS!

Maybe that numbers guy came up trumps in the woodshed after all !
Maybe also I shouldn't pick at the scab?

Rather (stills reconstruction).

This must be the reconstruction/documentary that Janet Bergstrom put together several years ago (and which was included on the Sunrise DVD). Even if new materials had been discovered, they wouldn't have been able to put a restoration together this quickly and, if they had, they would be making a big deal out of it, with screenings at major repertory venues, rather than just dumping it in a DVD box.

Beautiful. Not only are we getting the long awaited Borzage's (and then some more Borz, and then some more), but we're getting fucking CITY GIRL. We can all chuck aside those rips of the 16mm vhs.

WB & Universal should be ashamed of their danged selves. In the space of one year Fox pushes out a huge bulk of their silent classics. In the space of forever the other two can't even scratch the surface.

This is really exciting news. I just hope that they release individual films or small box sets as well as the mammoth one like they did with the Ford release. I bought the smaller Ford box sets for $20 on Amazon and the only things that were missing I just bought the singles, thus saving a lot more money.
Now we can only hope that Warner's will release their Borzage films on dvd soon.

Awesome. I hope they release a version of the box in Blu.

might have to wait for a blu moon!

I wouldnt hold my breath for blu silents from these guys now. Their B&W (and silent) telecine has been astronomically beautiful (I've been ad naeseum about the benchmark that Fox' Sunrise represented for their R1 as well as the MoC utilizing the same tape & extras) and, with materials like this, there's not much difference between a good HD pass/SD encode and a theatrical projection... much of which is a result of a talkback to celluloid of the digitally restored materials (like the recent janus prints of Regle).

Differences between SD/HD/35mm aside, I can't imagine Fox didn't create HD masters of these titles (especially since there was surely restoration involved). And since a box like this is marketed towards hardcore cinephiles -- many of whom will have gone Blu by Christmas -- why not humor us with some 1080 action?

Definitely as I said above, in agreement on an hd pass. Any major (hell any minor outside the budget lines like alpha etc) doing any new transfers in sd is in the stone age.

But I seriously doubt they'd print two bunches of a limited edition set like this, one Blu & one sd. They'd risk leftovers, which I'm sure they most emphatically dont want.

(Re the difs of HD & SD vs 35mm, remember I'm talking about silent films. I always go into theatrical projections of silents & pre-1935 vintage films hoping for some great visual revelation in terms of detail, and it just never happens... beyond the size of course).

If there are only eleven titles in the set, why would this be the case?

Wait a minute, are these two separate box sets or one "Fox Silents by Two Directors Maybe You've Heard Of" set?

It seems strange for this to be one set.

I would suspect these are all being done with 2K masters for future Blu releases. I think Criterion has been doing HD masters on all of their titles for the last few years. I think now they are even doing 4K masters.

Re the "combo" aspect--

Bergstrom explained it to me that it was going to be a "Showing the influence of Murnau at Fox box", with a combination of Murnau and Borzage. According to that formula I wouldnt have been surprised if something like Four Sons was thrown in.

But who cares-- just bundle it however they'd like and let it roll...

I would like this to be Blu as well, because it would demonstrate that properly restored and mastered silents can look fantastic at 1080p also. Plus seeing Sunrise in HD makes me nearly stain my trousers.

Schreck, do you know if the above list of 8 Borzage titles is the total tally, or, are there possibly more of his films to be included, but not yet announced?

Greatest, greatest thing to happen! No announcement could top this one, as far as I am concerned.

I just had a magnificent daydream about a Vidor/Sjostrom at MGM set coming out of Warners.

That might top this. Maybe. I don't know. I haven't seen any of the films that entail/would entail these proposed ideas; barring Sunrise, on which I am about to triple dip. But I'm very excited.

This dreamed box will be my dvd of the year.

Previously thought the Ford @ Fox was the greatest use of the dvd medium by any of the major studios... but it looks like this will trump that easy.

Scharf, as to your question above, Janet didn't give me exact numbers, or titles beyond the ones already mentioned (at least I don't think do.. I'd have to go way back and recheck that email- if I still have it).

I agree. I can't imagine any DVD or DVD set released this year (or next) topping this one. This bests (by far) even the Criterion Silent Ozu set.

Srsly.

But I mean, all it has to do is be what it says it is and will absolutely ipsofactorarily be the single best thing done with the dvd format ever. Beating maybe even Unseen Cinema by the Anthology here in NYC, which I think is still #1.

I always thought Sunrise should be a stand-alone release because of its reputation. But can't complain it's coming back on DVD.

You'll probably end up seeing that-- don't forget the way they made the most "classic" Ford titles available outa the @Fox box. At the very least, a couple, like Seventh Heaven/Street Angel, and Sunrise/City girl two-fers (though Sunrise w the Four Devils traces of a lost film and the gobs of extras really push the dl space to the edges, they'd have to release them, like Les Vampire was, on a dL flipper, four sides in all!).

This is good news indeed, the copy I saw of City Girl was atrociously bad and have been looking for Seventh Heaven for years. I was just reading something Molly Haskell wrote about Janet Gaynor and in particular her roles in the two Borzage films mentioned and kept thinking "man I can't wait until I can finally see those".

Fox has been making some good in roads, but I don't want to go out and say they're leading the way for major film studios film libraries considering how they've been so far behind up until now. Fox was about the worst in the VHS era and this is about the only way they can catch up. That said I pray for the day when Universal realizes what they have in their Paramount holdings and can finally release some fucking Von Sternberg films on DVD that don't star Marlene Dietrich.